Our popular bulletins and events will keep you abreast of the latest legal developments.

Our annual keynote seminar was held on Tuesday, 18 June 2019 at the Vale Resort. Speakers included Simon Evans, Peter Bennett, Amanda Evans and guest speaker, Steven Ford QC.

This edition considers a claim brought under the Occupiers’ Liability Act where the Claimant slipped and fell whilst visiting a leisure centre, as well as various case summaries.

This edition considers recent case-law regarding fundamental dishonesty, the meaning of ‘use of vehicle’ and apportioning liability for speeding.

Our annual keynote seminar was held on Tuesday, 18 June 2019 at the Vale Resort. Simon Evans considered the impact of the Civil Liability Act 2018, Peter Bennett provided a regulatory update and Amanda Evans and guest speaker, Steven Ford QC, discussed recent developments following CN v Poole BC [2019] UKSC 25.

Our monthly review of developments in the insurance and public sector. This edition considers a claim brought under the Occupiers’ Liability Act where the Claimant slipped and fell whilst visiting a leisure centre and case summaries relating to the recoverability of Counsel’s fees and the Court’s approach to Blamire awards.

This edition considers recent case-law regarding fundamental dishonesty, the necessity for bespoke life expectancy evidence, the meaning of ‘use of vehicle’ where a vehicle had been parked in a private garage which caught fire and apportioning liability for speeding.

Enquiries

Head Office

Capital Tower

Greyfriars Road

Cardiff

CF10 3AG

Tel: 029 2034 5531

BITC Cymru.jpg
Legal 500 Top Tier.jpg
Alarm Bronze.jpg
Cyber Essentials.png
Conveyancing Quality.jpg

© Copyright Dolmans Solicitors 2019. Dolmans Solicitors are authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority No. 48860

Whiplash Reform & Discount Rate (March 2018)

Civil Liability Bill 2018

On 20 March 2018, the Civil Liability Bill was introduced to the House of Lords dealing with two contentious issues in the personal injury compensation system of England and Wales, being compensation for whiplash injuries and the personal injury discount rate.

 

Readers may well recall that the then Chancellor, George Osborne, proposed reform to tackle the rising cost of motor insurance as long ago as 2016. Subsequently, there was the introduction of the Prisons and Courts Bill which, amongst other provisions, set out proposals for whiplash reform, but proceeded no further due to the announcement of the general election. In June 2017, the Queen’s speech announced that the Government would be tabling a Civil Liability Bill. 

 

In the interim, on 27 February 2017, Liz Truss, the then Lord Chancellor, changed the discount rate from 2.5% to - 0.75%, effective from 20 March 2017. The insurance industry was very critical of the change and, in particular, criticised the fundamental basis on which the discount rate was based on very low risk investment behaviour.

The Civil Liability Bill, unlike the Prison and Courts Bill, does not deal with the proposed changes to increase the small claims limit in road traffic related personal injury claims from £1,000 to £5,000 and for all personal injury claims from £1,000 to £2,000. Those issues are still being considered by the Civil Justice Committee.

Whiplash reform

 

The Bill provides for the following:

 

  • The introduction of a tariff of compensation for pain, suffering and loss of amenity for whiplash injury as defined within the Bill. The tariff itself has yet to be detailed and will be set out in secondary legislation in due course.

  • The introduction of a regulatory ban on settling or offering to settle whiplash claims without medical evidence.

  • Provides the judiciary with discretion to exceed the tariff for pain, suffering and loss of amenity in exceptional circumstances. There will be a limit for exceptional payments, which is to be set out in secondary legislation in due course.

  • Readers would be correct in concluding that the foregoing is nothing more than a repackaging of the provisions set out in the previously abandoned Prison and Courts Bill.

 

Discount rate

 

The change in the discount rate was made by Liz Truss under the powers conferred on her by the Damages Act 1996, guided by the 1999 case of Wells v Wells in which the Court determined that the discount rate should be based on the yields of Index Linked  Government Stock.

 

When the discount rate was reduced in February 2017, the Government appreciated this would lead to higher levels of compensation for those with future losses, and that not only would this impact negatively on insurers, but also on public services with large personal injury liabilities, particularly the NHS. Thereafter, there followed a consultation launched in March 2017 resulting in the Civil Liability Bill setting out measures to:

 

  • Establish a new basis for the calculation of the discount rate that continues to support the principle of 100% compensation, but also reflecting the reality of how Claimants actually invest damages.

  • Putting in place a process of setting the discount rate on a statutory footing with the Lord Chancellor to review the rate at least every 3 years. 

  • Establish an independent expert panel to advise the Lord Chancellor so as to ensure that the rate set is fair and transparent.

 

It is clear that the MOJ and Justice Committee have agreed that the discount rate should reflect "real-world" Claimant investment behaviour. The MOJ maintains that research by the Actuary Department indicates average awards may exceed the expected return by about 35%, although after an allowance is made for necessary expenses on tax and investment management, this figure may fall to between 20 to 25%. This is largely due to the way the current discount rate is calculated, making unrealistic assumptions about investment and returns. The MOJ have previously indicated that utilising the new proposed methodology may result in a discount rate of between 0 and 1%. The Justice Committee, on the other hand, has called for further evidence in relation to this issue before the draft legislation is progressed.

 

The introduction of the Bill is a clear indication that the Government remains committed to reforming the personal injury compensation system in England and Wales.